Interview Prep

Sell me this Pen – Best Interview Answer

How to answer “Sell me this pen” in an interview: ask questions first, find the need, then make your pitch.

Maria Hana

Updated 24 Oct 2026

8 min read

✓ 1:1 interview coaching available

Sell me this Pen – Best Interview Answer

Sell me this Pen: Have you faced this classic Interview Question? One of the things an interviewer is going to want to know about applicants for sales, marketing, and related jobs is whether they can sell, and what sales strategies and techniques they use.

Interviewers for sales jobs and other marketing positions may ask you to demonstrate your approach to selling a product as part of the interview. Be prepared to pitch a product or service, even though you don’t know what you will be asked to sell.

The point of the whole “Sell me this pen” is mostly used to identify if the person getting interviewed is in any way a good candidate for a sales job.

You might think this question is only likely to be asked if you work in sales but you’d be wrong. It can be asked of almost anyone, regardless of whether sales skills are important to their job. It’s a question that forces a candidate to think on their feet while under pressure and this can tell an interviewer a lot about a candidate, not least how clearly they are able to think and to communicate. It’s a classic question.

You might be asked to sell the interviewer a pen, a pencil, a stapler, an apple, or some other object.  As with other hypothetical questions, there will be no right answer, but the employer will be interested in the sales process that you follow, your verbal communication skills, and your enthusiasm and creativity.

Role-play questions are best practised out loud. If you’re interviewing for a project or leadership role, practise your answers in a live mock interview first.

Plan your conversation to avoid dead ends. One common trap: Starting your sales pitch by rattling off all the wonderful qualities of the pencil. Plus, after you list all the good things about the pencil, ask the interviewer if he wants to buy it, and he says no, you’ve run out of things to say most applicants fizzle after this happens. It’s OK to fake your confidence a bit to keep the conversation flowing. That beats sitting in silence.

Profile Review & Recommendation​​

Expert-Driven Profile Review &
Recommendations

Project Manager Interview Preparation image

Let our expert look into your CV, Cover Letter, Naukri & LinkedIn Profile to turn your profile into the top 1% of professional profiles.

INR 1,999

Self-Service Profile
Optimization

arrow

Access expert-curated guidelines, sample reviewed files, & step-by-step instructions to optimize your CV, Cover Letter, Naukri & LinkedIn Profile. 

INR 499

The only way to understand what the client wants is by asking questions. You cannot guess what the client needs. A great salesman knows that there is a reason we humans have two ears and only one mouth. We should let the client do the talking. How do you get the client talking? -by asking questions.

You sold them on the importance and practical uses of your product. Now in the next step, sell them on the emotional benefits of your product. Using the pen for writing a handwritten note.

Tell them a story. Highlight how you have started writing your spouse, parents, and friends handwritten notes. Get them thinking about someone in their life that they appreciate and that they would like to thank.

If, on the other hand, you don’t work in sales then this question is going to be a little trickier to handle. Don’t let yourself be panicked though, the interviewer knows full well that you are not used to selling and they won’t be expecting you to have a whole arsenal of sales techniques at your disposal. And don’t take yourself too seriously. Good people are always light-hearted and friendly.

Fact-checked against PMI’s current CCR rules · Last updated 24 Oct 2026

Leave a Comment

Limited to 10 slots a week

Live Mock Interview

Questions about your exam prep?

Chat with our team. Start chat →

Keep preparing with these guides

More interview guides like this one.

Prepare with an expert

Live 1:1 coaching for project, program and leadership interviews.

Coaching, real questions and a mock interview. From $59.

Live 1:1 executive preparation with a scorecard. From $149.

Live case labs with the Gururo Case Framework™. From $99.

JD-based interview, feedback within 24–48 hours.

Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.

Live Mock Interview

Scorecard in 24–48 hours

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top